COP31: A Little Less Offsetting, A Little More Accountability, please.

COP31 is concluding in Antalya, and perhaps it is time we had an uncomfortable conversation about carbon credits.

The year 2026 has been marked by increasingly severe climate events, including devastating floods, deadly heatwaves and prolonged droughts. Scientists have also warned that the world is on course to surpass the 1.5°C warming threshold established under the Paris Agreement, highlighting the growing urgency of global climate action.

For years, carbon offsetting has been presented as a convenient way for governments and businesses to balance their emissions while working towards climate targets. Keep emitting, purchase credits, make a carbon-neutral claim and move on. Sounds rather convenient, doesn't it?

Unfortunately, the reality is considerably more complicated.

As Australia attends the COP31 negotiations, a new United Nations report has raised serious questions about the credibility of carbon credits and the growing reliance on them as a climate solution.

The report, Rethinking Carbon Credits According to Climate and Human Rights Obligations, published by the UN Special Rapporteur on human rights and climate change, warns that governments relying on carbon credits to meet their climate commitments may be falling short of their international climate and human rights obligations.

And this is not simply a case of needing a few more rules and regulations.

The problem with buying your way out of emissions

The report identifies fundamental weaknesses in carbon credit markets, including conflicts of interest, inadequate transparency, incentives to overestimate emissions reductions.

There is also the uncomfortable issue of whether credits actually deliver the emissions reductions they promise.

Because purchasing a carbon credit is not the same thing as preventing an emission in the first place.

A financial transaction might balance an accounting figure, but it doesn't necessarily address the pollution being generated. Nor does it guarantee that the claimed environmental benefit is real, permanent or additional.

Perhaps we should be asking why so much attention is being given to buying credits, when the priority should be preventing emissions at their source.

And who is paying the price?

The concerns extend well beyond carbon accounting.

The UN report highlights the human rights implications of carbon projects, particularly for developing countries and Indigenous communities. While wealthier nations and major emitters may benefit from purchasing credits, the communities providing the land and resources for these projects can face land dispossession, restrictions on traditional livelihoods and cultural practices, and violations of their rights.

Meanwhile, significant financial benefits can flow to project developers and intermediaries rather than the communities directly affected.

It raises a rather uncomfortable question: who is really benefiting from the carbon credit economy, and who is being asked to carry the consequences?

A convenient excuse to keep burning fossil fuels?

The concern is that offsetting can allow governments and industries to maintain their dependence on fossil fuels while presenting an appearance of climate progress.

It is difficult to claim leadership on climate action while continuing to support fossil fuel expansion and relying on carbon credits to compensate for the resulting emissions.

At some point, accountability has to mean more than purchasing your way out of responsibility.

Australia's position on climate change is facing increasing scrutiny, particularly when the scale of its fossil fuel exports is considered. Australia's contribution to global warming doesn't stop at its own borders. By supplying international markets with vast quantities of coal, natural gas and oil, the country is also exporting a substantial carbon footprint.

Research published by Global Witness, based on official Australian government figures, highlights the enormous international impact of the country's exported fossil fuels. The emissions generated by these exports over the ten years after the Paris Agreement were greater than the total domestic emissions produced by 44 of the world's poorest nations combined.

But the figures do not end there. Government projections indicate that a further 6.9 billion tonnes of CO₂ equivalent could be associated with Australia's fossil fuel exports by 2031.

Combined, this would bring estimated export-related emissions between 2016 and 2032 to an extraordinary 19.3 billion tonnes of CO₂ equivalent.

Perhaps most concerning is what this means for the global climate budget. That volume represents approximately 3.4% of the remaining carbon budget, measured from a 2016 baseline, for maintaining a reasonable chance of limiting global warming to 1.5°C.

Australia may account for only a fraction of the world's population, but its fossil fuel exports carry consequences far beyond its shores.

Pressure is mounting from within Australia, too.

Concerns have also been raised internationally about Australia's approach to carbon offsetting. UN human rights experts have warned that carbon credit schemes risk giving large emitters an alternative to making meaningful changes to their operations, allowing them to purchase credits instead of prioritising direct emissions reductions.

The uncomfortable question is whether Australia is genuinely leading the transition to a lower-carbon future, or simply finding increasingly convenient ways to maintain business as usual.

Australia's Climate Targets: Ambition on Paper, But Is It Enough?

Australia's emissions commitments are coming under increasing scrutiny as the gap between climate science and government targets attracts attention. Depending on how strictly emissions from heavy industry, transport, and land-use changes are tracked, Climate Analytics estimates Australia's true 1.5°C-compatible target range is 76% to 89% by 2035 to align with the Paris Agreement's goal of limiting global warming to 1.5°C.

Australia's current commitment, however, sets a different benchmark. The Federal Government has pledged to reduce emissions by 62–70% below 2005 levels by 2035, followed by a net zero target for 2050.

The difference raises an important question: are Australia's existing commitments consistent with the scale and urgency of the emissions reductions required?

There is a growing disconnect between what climate science indicates is necessary and what governments are prepared to commit to politically.

And if Australia is serious about climate leadership, perhaps the question should not be how ambitious its targets look compared with other countries, but whether they are actually ambitious enough to make a difference.

So, what should genuine climate action look like?

Carbon credits may have a legitimate role in addressing emissions that cannot reasonably be eliminated. But they should come after meaningful efforts to reduce emissions, not instead of them.

For businesses, that means starting with accurate measurement of their environmental footprint, identifying the major sources of emissions and developing practical reduction strategies.

Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) provides a recognised methodology for understanding environmental impacts across a product's life cycle, helping businesses identify where improvements can make a measurable difference.

Credible climate action starts with knowing your actual environmental impact, not simply finding ways to compensate for it.

Measure what you emit. Reduce what you can. Take responsibility for what remains.

Because the world does not need more impressive carbon-neutral claims. It needs genuine emissions reductions, transparent reporting and businesses and governments prepared to be held accountable.

A little less offsetting. A little more accountability, please.

Read more about the Sources:

Next
Next

COP31: Measuring, (thinking about) reducing emissions and another round of discussions or something more?